Log in Subscribe

Notes to Consider- America 250 Presidents Timeline Project (Manifest Destiny Era)

7. Andrew Jackson (Democrat) 1828-1836 Foreign Policy Big Idea: Indian Removal Act

Posted

“I’m from the government, and I’m here to help.” Our collective recollections of all US Government dealings with the Indians conjure up the sentiments of that apocryphal quote from a President Reagan speech. As referenced previously, such widely held, pat recollections of American History fail to give us the full picture; more on that later.

As a westerner, Andrew Jackson’s dealings with Indians were very much personal, not merely theoretical as was already the case along the long past settled Eastern Seaboard. Men such as our own William Whitley and the Tennessean Jackson were under no illusions; there was to be only one group of permanent occupants of the Trans-Appalachian West. Based upon the argument that if large Indian populations remained east of the Mississippi River they would face eventual extinction; the Indian Removal Act of 1830 gave Indians the proposition of either incorporating themselves as citizens of the southeastern states in which they lived, or be relocated as tribes west of the Mississippi River.

In the classic demonstration of the fact our government is truly divided amongst three branches, the US Supreme Court sided with Georgia Cherokees against their removal in Worcester vs. Georgia. President Jackson simply ignored the court’s orders. “Boy. The Court then showed him!” Uh, no. As President Jackson famously put it: “John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it!” The principle applies today as surely as it did in 1832: The US Supreme Court issues “opinions,” not “laws.”

In other words, it is only through gentlemen’s agreements for putting arguments to rest that the Court gets its “authority.” (The Court’s — all courts — defined constitutional roles are to apply the laws as written, and/or to hear appeals.) Finally, to the reference in the introduction of the one-sided remembrance of settler-Indian relations in our collective minds.

Just a few weeks ago marked 240 years since the McNitt Company consisting of 27 men, women, and children were making their way from Virginia towards Ft. Logan (present day Stanford, Kentucky). While camped near the Little Laurel River along Boone’s Trace (inside present-day Levi Jackson Wilderness Road Park), a pack of Indians bushwacked and massacred in cold blood 24 of the peaceful white immigrants.* There were countless other mass murders/mutilations of settlers (Curiously, often referred to on historical markers as “defeats,” not honestly as “massacres.”) on the western frontier.

Those incidents are never covered in classrooms. Why? (Be honest. How many of you reading this piece knew the level of savagery of the McNitt Company Massacre until today? How about the Starns “Defeat” at the foot of Big Hill in which a white man’s heart was ripped from his chest? Those are but two right here in our own backyard.) *William Whitley (as he did so many times) avenged the McNitt Company with even more Indian blood. White-Indian relations (locally/nationally) were not cartoonish, one-sided affairs.

Next Week: President Andrew Jackson Domestic Policy Big Idea Happy Veterans Day to all those who have ever stood in the breach.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here